Package Details: yt-dlp-git 2021.08.02.r38.gb6a35ad83-1

Git Clone URL: https://aur.archlinux.org/yt-dlp-git.git (read-only, click to copy)
Package Base: yt-dlp-git
Description: A youtube-dl fork with additional features and fixes (git)
Upstream URL: https://github.com/yt-dlp/yt-dlp
Licenses: Unlicense
Conflicts: yt-dlp
Provides: yt-dlp
Submitter: katt
Maintainer: katt
Last Packager: katt
Votes: 7
Popularity: 3.80
First Submitted: 2021-08-08 15:20
Last Updated: 2021-08-08 15:20

Latest Comments

katt commented on 2021-09-04 09:02

@Hekuran That's entirely down to personal preference, personally I am fine with the normal package, plus it's only a makedepend anyway. I'm sure your favourite AUR helper can solve this as well.

Hekuran commented on 2021-09-04 07:15

@katt as i have been told by @m040601 i deleted my pkg, since there was no need for it. When i have searched the aur web there was no "*-git", so i made one, but as your srcinfo says, you seem to be older :shrug: . The only difference was that i used pandoc-bin.

So, could you also use pandoc-bin so that it won't pull 130 dependencies, that would be great, for everyone.

katt commented on 2021-09-02 19:13

@m040601 Pretty sure I am in the clear here, the other ones (that are -git) either don't work or have the wrong name.

m040601 commented on 2021-09-02 15:35

EDIT: someone has also suggested:

...to discuss this issue in the aur mailinglist? Let's offload this decision to the arch TUs and implement whatever they think is appropriate. ...

ORIGINAL COMMENT: May I suggest that the maintainer of this PKGBUILD talk and negotiate with the the maintainers of similar PKGBUILD's ?

With such a fast changing thing like youtube-dl and its variants, by having many eyeballs watching the same PKGBUILD's, this would also means less work for you, the maintainer.

There seems to be a lot of interest in using yt-dlp as a replacement for youtube-dl. This has led to a lot of PKGBUILD's being created in AUR, like mushrooms doing apparentely the same thing.

This:

  • confuses users, which one to install ? Which one will still be here maintained in x months ?
  • is a complete waste of man power and reduplicating work,
  • disperses user votes, maybe one day, with enough votes, yt-dlp could be an official Arch package,without any need for PKGBUILD.

We basicly only need a yt-dlp "normal one", "-git" one and eventually a "-bin" one.

With such a fast changing thing like youtube-dl, by having many eyeballs watching the same PKGBUILDS, this would also means less work for you, the maintainer.

Some more additionally facts:

  • yt-dlp is officially called ... hhh... "yt-dlp". It is not officially called "youtube-dlp"
  • ...